Friday, March 20, 2009

SUMMARY OF DAWN'S SITUATION: LETTER TO MAL BROUGH

Below is an important letter Dawn wrote to Federal minister Mal Brough two and a half years ago, which addresses many of the key issues from Dawn's perspective:

*****

Dawn Rowan
PO Box 60
St Andrews

VIC 3761

18 October 2006

FOR THE URGENT ATTENTION OF:

The Honourable Mal Brough MP
Minister for Families, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs
Box 7788
Canberra Mail Centre ACT 2610



Dear Minister,
Re: Bankruptcy Proceedings Issued By The Australian Government Solicitor
I am writing to you in the hope that you will be able to assist me with respect to bankruptcy proceedings that have been instituted against me following sixteen years of litigation. Although I was successful in that litigation the outcome has had a catastrophic effect on me, my health and my career. It has now culminated with the Commonwealth serving me with a Bankruptcy Notice no doubt with the ultimate intention of forcing me into bankruptcy.
I am approaching you in the hope that you will intervene and bring an end to what has been a disastrous last fifteen years of my life.
In the briefest terms can I explain.
Background
I was born in 1946 and educated in Adelaide.
I chose to follow a career as a secondary school music teacher and did so for ten years.
Thereafter I was interested in directing my activities to counselling women and children who had been subject to domestic violence and cruelty. I undertook and completed a degree of Bachelor of Social Administration and applied for and was ultimately appointed the administrator of two women’s shelters in Adelaide.
The shelters were jointly funded by the Commonwealth and State Governments and from 1978 myself and a number of other workers devoted ourselves to counselling and assisting a large number of people who attended the shelters for assistance.

Joint Report – Defamation
On 11 August 1987 a report was published by a joint committee which had been set up by the State and Federal Governments. The report was from an independent review committee which had been commissioned to examine the management and operation of the women’s shelters.
The report was ultimately published and received extensive media coverage from television stations and the press. The report contained unwarranted and untruthful allegations of sexual and financial impropriety on the part of myself and others associated with the management of the shelters.
The impact of the report was devastating. I had devoted my career and life to counselling women and children and given up everything to pursue this career. I had considered it was a most worthwhile cause and I had intended to devote my life to that career.
As a consequence of the report, funding was withdrawn and the Christies Beach shelter closed.
The impact on my health was immediate and I remained on sickness benefits for two years.
I fled the State and relocated in Victoria, but my professional reputation, my ambitions and my health had been effectively destroyed.
I was left without means of income.
Although I obtained some employment in Victoria for approximately twelve months I ultimately had to resign from that position because of my health and political pressure.
Litigation
Because the allegations in the report were completely false and misleading, because my career had been ruined and I was without income I took legal advice and commenced defamation proceedings out of the Supreme Court in South Australia.
Whilst I had little in the way of funds, I obtained legal representation and proceedings were instituted on 26 June 1990.
The Defendants to the proceedings were the authors of the report (these being the State and Commonwealth employees, as well as the State and Federal Governments). I also sued the two television stations who had published the findings of the report.
The legal proceedings were extensive and protracted and the Defendants for the next ten years took numerous steps to have the proceedings defeated.
The trial eventually commenced in June 2001 and proceeded for sixty-seven days. For sixty of those days I was without legal representation and fought the case on my own.
The State, the Commonwealth and the television stations were all represented by Counsel, an army of solicitors and in some cases Queens Counsel.
In a judgment delivered on 21 June 2002 Justice Debelle, a senior and highly regarded member of the bench published his reasons. He described the allegations as a “shocking defamation”.
I was ultimately awarded the sum of approximately $585,000 in damages, together with the costs of the action.
In subsequent contribution proceedings the amount to which the Commonwealth was found liable to pay was $39,117.42.
Although the award of compensation was less than I had expected I felt that my action in bringing the litigation had been vindicated. Needless to say the years in preparing the case for trial, the trauma of fighting the case in court without legal representation and the associated affect on my health meant that I had been without income for virtually all of that period.
Appeals
Because of apparent unlimited resources the State, the Commonwealth and the two television stations all lodged appeals.
In order to defend the judgment I was forced to retain solicitors and barristers.
My health deteriorated, I was unable to work and spent a vast amount of time instructing lawyers to defend the appeals.
I was required to sell a property which had been left to me by my mother in order to pay legal costs associated with the appeal and the subsequent appeal to the High Court.
Eventually the Full Court allowed the appeal.
For reasons for which I am unable to understand the two television stations and the Commonwealth were exonerated. The damages awarded to me were reduced, but I retained the judgment against the State of South Australia.
Whilst I was awarded 75% of my costs against the State, I was ordered to pay the costs of the Commonwealth and the two television stations.
The total claims for costs of the Commonwealth and the two television stations exceeded $1 million and the liability to pay these sums would have meant that even though I had succeeded in the litigation overall, the result would have been my bankruptcy.
Faced with this I had no further alternative than to instruct my lawyers to appeal to the High Court.
Because the High Court considered that the matter was not of public interest and only involved legal costs my application for special leave to appeal was refused.

Subsequent Action by the Commonwealth
The end of the court processes left me in poor health and financially ruined as I faced costs orders of the television stations and the Commonwealth of over $1 million.
The two television stations have not pursued me for their legal costs. The Commonwealth, however, has been relentless.
Since the dismissal of the High Court proceedings the Australian Government Solicitor, on behalf of the Commonwealth, has:
• Made a demand for costs in excess of $600,000.
• Obtained an injunction against me, freezing my assets.
• Relentlessly pursued the claim for costs against me and eventually obtained an order for lump sum payment of costs of $380,000.
• Issued a Bankruptcy Notice against me with a view to obtaining a Bankruptcy Order.
As a consequence of this I have had funds from the sale of a house that I owned frozen and have had access to my bank accounts limited.
In September 2005, in the course of the injunction proceedings, I requested my solicitors to write to the AGS outlining my position. I requested that my situation be referred to the Minister with a view that the Australian Government Solicitor be instructed to refrain from pursuing its claim against me.
I enclose herewith a copy of the letter that my solicitors sent to the AGS, together with the medical report that was referred to in that letter.
I do not know what transpired as a result of that letter.
The Current Position
The Bankruptcy Notice issued by the Australian Government Solicitor demands payment of $380,000 by 17 October 2006. I presume that if that sum is not paid the Australian Government Solicitor will issue a petition against me with a view to having me declared bankrupt.
I do not know if the two television stations will join in those proceedings, but to date neither of them have made demands against me for costs. I believe that if the Commonwealth were to withdraw its demand the two television stations would not pursue me.
My current position is as follows:
• I have a house at St Andrews in Victoria. It is my home and a place where I am trying to re-establish my practice as a counsellor. The house is valued at about $500,000, but is subject to a mortgage of nearly $130,000.
• I previously had a holiday home at Coronet Bay in Victoria. This was sold in August 2005 for $190,000. Those funds were frozen by the Commonwealth as part of its court proceedings and are currently in a solicitor’s trust account in Melbourne.
• There is a balance of about $30,000 held by the State Crown being the balance of court costs due to me. The State, however, is claiming $17,000 of that sum.
• Overall I have spent over $380,000 in legal fees and have no money in the bank. All of my personal financial resources have gone into the litigation over the last fifteen years. I have less than $40,000 in a superannuation fund.
The Future
As a result of the last fifteen years I remain shattered and confused. I have ten years of my working life left, but with no realistic prospect of obtaining fulltime work or employment.
If the bankruptcy proceedings continue I will certainly lose my house and everything that I have worked for over the years.
With the limited finances that I have I would prefer to attempt to rebuild my career as a counsellor and attempt to retain my health and my dignity. I do not want to lose my home and become reliant on Centrelink payments.
Although the Commonwealth was excused from liability by the Full Court, there is no doubt that its officers were involved in the preparation of the report that ultimately was found to be grossly defamatory and which ruined my career. Although the television stations were involved in the defamatory conduct they have exercised clemency and have not to date pursued their claims for costs against me. It is only the Commonwealth that has adopted a relentless approach to have me ruined.
In the circumstances, therefore, I am again asking for clemency with the request that you intervene and instruct your department to refrain from pursuing its claim for legal costs.
I have forwarded a copy of this letter to the Australian Government Solicitor with the request that it take no further bankruptcy proceedings pending your consideration of my position.
I would be most appreciative of any assistance that you are able to afford.
I remain yours sincerely

DAWN ROWAN

Copy to:
The Hon Philip Ruddock MP
ATTORNEY-GENERAL

41 comments:

逛街 said...

你的部落格很棒,我期待更新喔........................................

好好笑 said...

全裸打炮打手槍打飛機巨乳巨奶女優大奶性交性愛淫蕩淫慾淫亂淫婦淫妹淫叫淫水淫女情慾情色做愛限制級波霸口交18禁貼圖寫真視訊援交露點爆乳潮吹裸體裸照

陽明山花季 said...

淫亂火辣美女本土av情色視訊聊天免費色情網站性經驗色情成人影片色情視訊聊天av圖av情色情趣娃娃成人電影院淫蕩18禁色情電話情色成人網辣妹自拍台灣av女優台灣情色春宮台灣色情成人網站0401影音g點成人vcd情色影片520sex性愛圖視訊妹調情視訊美女聊天美女性交台灣性樂園成人影像走光打砲裸女寫真美女裸照露奶激突論壇情色圖片做愛線上a片做愛視訊情色成人成人交友穿幫色情a片情色全裸入鏡台灣情色網

姿英姿英 said...

做愛色情片做愛色情影片免費色情論壇色情網小說色情秀性愛片試看性愛自慰高潮影片性愛色情片性愛色情影片性愛免費短片性愛刺激性愛呻吟性愛姿勢大全性愛昭式性愛敏感地帶性愛短片免費看性愛圖網東洋無碼動畫下載區亞洲線上免費杜雷斯成人貼圖杜蕾斯貼片區杜蕾斯貼圖片區杜蕾斯貼圖網杜蕾斯漫畫杜蕾斯影片分享杜蕾斯線上片杉本彩寫真集杉原杏璃影片男人貼圖站男女免費線上影片視訊辣妹亞洲情色風暴貼圖杜蕾斯成人拓網交友

明偉誠秋 said...

Actions speak louder than words. ........................................

怡帆 said...

thank for share, it is very important . ̄︿ ̄

BertR_Dimarco223965 said...

may the blessing be always with you!! ........................................

IdellaD_Bar3321 said...

能付出愛心就是福;能消除煩惱就是慧。........................................

BurtonClary031 said...

文章很棒~感謝!!..................................................

季洪雅 said...

喔!最悲慘的事並非夭折早逝,而是當我活到七十五歲,卻發現自己從未真正活過。 ..................................................

信定 said...

Every moment of resistance to temptation is a victory. ....................................................

韋于倫成 said...

肯定與支持你!!!加油囉~.........................

健豪 said...

No pains, no gains...................................................

正玲正玲 said...

很用心的blog,推推哦 ..................................................

LeanneC珮瑜 said...

你不能改變容貌~~但你可以展現笑容............................................................

sdas said...

you look nice in that color!............................................................

RoseH_Huls21365 said...

時間就是靈魂的生命。......................................................................

林奕廷 said...

休息才能再次出發-隨時保持好體力-加油.................................................................

韋以 said...

知識可以傳授,智慧卻不行。每個人必須成為他自己。......................................................................

江婷 said...

may the blessing be always with you!!.................................................................                           

貴寶 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

林怡潔 said...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

張怡 said...

馬丁路德:「即使知道明天世界即將毀滅,我仍願在今天種下一棵小樹。」............................................................

吳婷婷 said...

如果你批評他人。你就沒有時間付出愛............................................................

吳婷婷 said...

人生最可憐的是半途而廢,最可悲的是喪失信心,最遺憾的是浪費時間,最可怕的是沒有恆心。..................................................

吳婷婷 said...

大師手筆﹐果然不凡............................................................

冠宇 said...

沈舟側畔千帆過,病樹前頭萬木春............................................................

宥妃宥妃 said...

good, excellent, nice job!!............................................................

洪瑋婷洪瑋婷 said...

堅持是為著某種目的或目標,而持續不斷朝向既定方向努力的一種意念。..................................................

雅俊芬凱陳許 said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。..................................................

DaniloM_W志竹olff0615 said...

缺少智慧,就是缺少一切..................................................

林思楊偉馨沛 said...

凡事三思而行,跑得太快是會滑倒的。.......................................................

張陳俊凱柏 said...

It is easier to get than to keep it.......................................................................

佳呈均慧 said...

一個人的價值,應該看他貢獻了什麼,而不是他取得了什麼....................................................

劉王育正劉王育正 said...

鞋匠能作好鞋子,因為他只做鞋,不做別的。..................................................

红意 said...

死亡是悲哀的,但活得不快樂更悲哀。. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

智柏林婉林亞 said...

堅持是為著某種目的或目標,而持續不斷朝向既定方向努力的一種意念。..................................................

怡靜怡靜怡靜怡雯 said...

不會從失敗中找尋教訓的人,成功之路是遙遠的。.................................................

佳張張張張燕張張張張張 said...

時間就是塑造生命的材料。

孟湖聿軒 said...

看到好文章心情就很好 ^^

苗承凡 said...

看看文章轉換心情,也幫你加個油哦............................................................